Urban Development Policy Making

Urban Development Policy Making

Redefining the Shrine-City Bond: A Comprehensive Spatial Sustainability Framework Focused on Safeguarding Pilgrimage Etiquette and the Rights of Neighbors; Case Study of the Shah Abdol-Azim Hasani Shrine

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Associate Professor, Department of Urban and Regional Planning and Design, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
2 M.Sc. in Urban Planning, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
10.22034/judpm.2026.590284.1137
Abstract
Historically, religious centers served as the identity-forming heartbeat of Iranian-Islamic cities. However, recent object-oriented interventions have triggered "islandification" and spatial rupture from the surrounding fabric. Adopting a holistic, quasi-experimental methodology, this research maps the sustainability of the Shah Abdol-Azim Hasani Shrine precinct to redefine development models for these sensitive areas. The study’s innovation lies in a comprehensive four-dimensional framework_incorporating "quality of life," "social justice," "economic inclusiveness," and "pilgrimage etiquette"_evaluated through spatial statistical analysis and surveys of authorities, pilgrims, and neighbors. Findings reveal a sharp sustainability contrast: while "acquisition and demolition" in the southern zone (Nafarabad) led to social collapse and indigenous displacement, the western zone (Sartakht) maintained dynamism through "spontaneous renovation" and local identity preservation. The analysis demonstrates that a dominant commercial approach prioritizing short-term pilgrim needs has degraded the quality of life for neighbors, worsened traffic, and fueled spatial-economic inequality.This paper proposes an exit strategy through three fundamental paths: managing stakeholder conflicts of interest; strengthening spatial-functional continuity between the shrine and the city; and a vital shift from "spatial commercialization" toward "reinforcing residential functions" to restore sustainable life. This approach offers a novel framework for integrated governance in religious urban fabrics, ensuring a balance between sacred duties and urban vitality.
Keywords
Subjects

1.    UN-Habitat, Ministry of Municipal and Rural Affairs. Makkah city profile: Future Saudi Cities Programme. Riyadh: Ministry of Municipal and Rural Affairs; 2019.
2.    Farhan SL, Hasan SA, Rahim LA, Ebraheem AK, Al-Hussaini ZIH, Ebraheem MA, Alkinani AS, Al-Rawe MK, Jassim AH, Shok ME. Balancing Heritage Preservation and Sustainable Development in Historic Cities: A Case Study of Old Najaf in the Context of Global Best Practices. Int J Sustain Dev Plan. 2025;20(3):1041-1051. doi:10.18280/ijsdp.200311
3.    Al Ameen Z, Font Basté MG, Martí Audí N. Reuse strategies of urban areas and built heritage: case study of Karbala Old City. Environ Sci Sustain Dev. 2025;10(2):13-27. doi:10.21625/essd.v10i2.1154
4.    Dehkordi MQ, Nedaei Toosi S. Spatial mapping of deterioration in the heritage area of Shiraz as a consequence of urban regeneration interventions. Shahri. 2025;9(1):1-18. [In Persian]. doi:10.22034/SHAHRI.2025.463221.1162
5.    Dehkordi MQ, Nedaei Toosi S. Investigating intervention inefficiency and deterioration in the heritage area of Shiraz. Sustain Urban Dev. 2025;7(2):71-90. [In Persian]. doi:10.22059/SUD.2025.384921.1345.
6.    Dehkordi MQ, Nedaei Toosi S. A sustainable framework for intervention and heritage regeneration: A systematic review. Bagh-e Nazar. 2024;21(121):5-22. [In Persian]. doi:10.22034/BAGH.2024.438687.6118
7.    Mashayekhi A, Dianati V, Vaghefi I. Revolutionary Charitable Foundations and Politics of Land Acquisition and Land Conflict in Peri-Urban Areas of Tehran. City: Analysis of Urban Change, Theory, Action. 2026. doi:10.1080/13604813.2025.2608445
8.    Farhan SL, Abdelmonem MG, Nasar ZA. The urban transformation of traditional city centres: Holy Karbala as a case study. ArchNet-IJAR. 2018;12(3):53-67. doi:10.26687/archnet-ijar.v12i3.1625
9.    Al-Daini RK, Asadi S, Danilina NV. Strategic urban planning of religious cities: the case study of Karbala city in Iraq. Vestn MGSU. 2020;15(8):1081-1089. doi:10.22227/1997-0935.2020.8.1081-1089
10.              Shyju PJ, Bhat IA, Myers K, Tanwar N. Local stakeholders' perspectives on religious heritage and tourism development in Varanasi. Int J Tour Cities. 2020;6(3):529-544. doi:10.1108/IJTC-10-2019-0194
11.              Farhan SL, Khalel Merie UAA, Alobaydi D. Challenges and opportunities of the urban structures of holy cities: the case of Old Najaf, Iraq. In: Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Smart Cities and Sustainable Planning. IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci. 2023;1129(1):012034. doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1129/1/012034
12.              Eshaghian F, Hosseini A, Seyedolhosseini SM. Evaluation of the renovation and rehabilitation plan of Sector 2 of the area surrounding the Holy Shrine with emphasis on physical and functional dimensions. In: Proceedings of the 4th Conference on Urban Planning and Management; 2012 May 9–10; Mashhad, Iran. [In Persian]
13.              Sabouri S, Saboonchi P. A qualitative assessment of the peripheral texture development of a holy site (case study: Imam Reza Street). Manzar. 2022;14(61):44-55. [In Persian]. doi:10.22034/MANZAR.2022.306319.2154
14.              Eslami SH, Zamani B, Nouraei H. Developing an urban design framework for the precincts of pilgrimage shrines using a comprehensive territorial approach: case study of the urban fabric surrounding the Shrine of Hazrat Masoumeh (SA). Nameh Memari Shahrsazi. 2022;14(34). [In Persian]
15.              Abbachi S, Farhoodi R, Gharakhlou M, Hosseini SB. State-led approach to urban regeneration and dependent gentrification: Analysis of key stakeholders' performance in the renewal of the Mashhad shrine surrounding area. Urban Stud. 2018;7(27):45-62. [In Persian]
16.              Sarkheili A, Pourjafar M, Rafieian M. Assessing the effects of the convergence of religion and economy on the urban form of Samen District, Mashhad. Hoviat-e Shahr. 2014;8(15):41-54. [In Persian]
17.              Jandaghi Meybodi A, Gholami S, Mirkatouli J, Barati MA. Investigating the factors affecting owners' and residents' participation in financing residential land uses in the renovation and rehabilitation plan of the area surrounding the Holy Shrine of Imam Reza. J Urban Econ Manag. 2020;8(32):187-208. [In Persian]
18.              Pourzargar M, Abedini H. Explaining the components of modernization and quality enhancement in the adjacent fabric of Imamzadeh Saleh Shrine. Naqsh-e Jahan Journal. 2020;10(1). [Persian]
19.              Al-Eslami AT, Rouhi Mirabadi Z. Analysis of urban spaces surrounding sacred places in relation to pilgrims' needs and behavioral patterns: Case study of Imam Reza Street, Mashhad. Armanshahr Arch Urban Plan. 2020;13(31):97-111. [In Persian]
20.              Maroufi H, Rosina E. Cities hosting holy shrines: The impact of pilgrimage on urban form. ICONARP Int J Archit Plan. 2017;5(2):30-44.
21.              Saeedi A. Community participation in conservation proposals of Islamic pilgrimage sites. In: Proceedings of the Society of Architectural Historians Australia and New Zealand. 2021. p.470-483.
22.              Alateby A. Tourism and recreation in the State of Kuwait: A geographical study. J Gulf Stud Arab. 2002;107:155.
23.              Al-Janaby S. City center and its impact on the urban complex. J Iraqi Geogr Soc. 1985;16:46.
24.              Hutchinson F, Herborn P. Landscapes for peace: A case study of active learning about urban environments and the future. Futures. 2012;44(1):24-35.
25.              Kapoor S, Nayak BK, Sehgal V. Establishing an "experiential priority index" for sustainable heritage planning in religious-historic cities. Urban Sci. 2026;10(1):14. doi:10.3390/urbansci10010014
26.              Saliba R. Framing urban design on the margins: global paradigms and regional implications. In: Saliba R, editor. Urban Design in the Arab World: Reconceptualizing Boundaries. London: Ashgate; 2015. p. 1-16
27.              Naghizadeh M. Theory of the Life of Taybee, or the Ideal City of Islam. Tehran: Olum Tahghigh Publications; 2016.
28.              Golkar K. Creating Sustainable Place. Tehran: Shahid Beheshti University Press; 2014
29.              Habibi A, Jalalnia R. Phenomenology [book in Persian]. Tehran: Naroon Publications; 2022
30.              Hsieh HF, Shannon SE. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res. 2005;15(9):1277-1288. doi:10.1177/1049732305276687
Volume 3, Issue 4 - Serial Number 9
Autumn 2027
Pages 733-760

  • Receive Date 27 June 2026
  • Revise Date 23 July 2026
  • Accept Date 23 September 2026
  • Publish Date 01 January 2027