Urban Development Policy Making

Urban Development Policy Making

Simulating Housing Demand Recomposition under Changes in Housing Prices, Household Income, and Education: A Multistage Discrete Choice Framework

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Urban Economics Researcher, PhD in Economics, Tehran, Iran
2 Full Professor, Department of Economic Development and Planning, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran
3 Assistant Professor, Department of Economic Development and Planning, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran
10.22034/judpm.2026.580703.1101
Abstract
The housing market is closely linked to household welfare, residential security, income distribution, and social stability, making it a central area of economic and urban policy. However, much of the existing literature examines the effects of economic changes mainly on aggregate housing demand, while households often respond by reallocating their demand across different housing alternatives. This article investigates the effects of housing price changes, household income, and educational attainment on the recomposition of housing demand using a multistage discrete choice econometric approach. Housing alternatives are classified into 24 categories based on tenure status, dwelling type, and unit size. Households are also grouped into 15 income–education categories by combining income quintiles with three levels of household head education. The empirical data were obtained from the Household Income and Expenditure Survey conducted by the Statistical Center of Iran in 2023, covering a sample of 18,049 Iranian households. The empirical framework is based on three discrete choice models: a binary logit model for tenure choice, a multinomial logit model for dwelling type, and an ordered logit model for housing size. Three simulation scenarios are then examined: a 10 percent increase in housing prices, a 10 percent increase in household income, and a one-year increase in education. The results show that higher housing prices reduce homeownership, increase rental demand, and shift demand toward smaller and apartment units while reducing demand for large non-apartment dwellings. In contrast, higher household income strengthens homeownership and increases demand for larger and non-apartment units. Education has a similar but weaker effect compared with income. The findings also indicate that lower-income households are more sensitive to all scenarios. These results suggest that housing policy should consider not only aggregate demand but also changes in demand composition, with particular emphasis on targeted support for low-income households, the supply of small and medium-sized units, and rental market regulation.
JEL Classification: R21, R31, C35, C25, D12, I24.
Keywords
Subjects

1.  Goodman AC. An econometric model of housing price, permanent income, tenure choice, and housing demand. Journal of Urban Economics. 1988;23(3):327-53.
2.  Goodman AC, Kawai M. Functional form, sample selection and housing demand. Journal of Urban Economics. 1986;20:155-67.
3.  Kim K-H, Park S, Cho M, You SD. Housing affordability, borrowing constraints and tenure choice in Korea. International Journal of Urban Sciences. 2020.
4.  Morais MP, Cruz BO. Housing demand, tenure choice, and housing policy in Brazil. In: Lall SV, Freire M, Yuen B, Rajack R, Helluin J-J, editors. Urban land markets: Improving land management for successful urbanization: The World Bank/Springer; 2009.
5.  Morais MP, Cruz BO. Escolha das condições de ocupação da moradia e política habitacional no Brasil. Boletim Regional, Urbano e Ambiental. 2011;6. Ipea.
6.  Clark WAV, Dieleman FM. Households and housing: Choice and outcomes in the housing market: Center for Urban Policy Research; 1996.
7.  Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University. The state of the nation’s housing 2024: Harvard University; 2024.
8.  Quigley JM, Raphael S. Is housing unaffordable? Why isn’t it more affordable? Journal of Economic Perspectives. 2004;18(1):191-214.
9.  Bertaud A. Housing affordability in China: A stock and flow model approach. 2010.
10.       Gan Q, Hill JR. Measuring housing affordability: Looking beyond the median. Journal of Housing Economics. 2009;18(2):115-25.
11.       Meen G. How should housing affordability be measured?: UK Collaborative Centre for Housing Evidence; 2018.
12.       Baker E, Beer A, Leishman C, Vij A, Stone W, Morey C, et al. Planning for a two-tenure future (AHURI Final Report No. 431): Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited; 2024.
13.       Burke T, Nygaard C, Ralston L. Australian home ownership: Past reflections, future directions (AHURI Final Report No. 328): Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited; 2020.
14.       Baker E, Bentley R, Beer A, Daniel L. Renting in the time of COVID-19: Understanding the impacts (AHURI Final Report No. 340): Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited; 2020.
15.       Gurran N, Phibbs P. Boulevard of broken dreams: Planning, housing supply and affordability in urban Australia. Built Environment. 2016;42(1):55-71.
16.       Druta O, Ronald R, Heath S. Urban singles and shared housing. Social & Cultural Geography. 2021;22(9):1195-203.
17.       Goodall Z, Stone W, Cook K. Housing policy and non-commercial shared housing in the private rental sector: A scoping review. Housing Studies. 2024;39(11):2919-37.
18.       Maalsen S. ‘Generation share’: Digitalised geographies of shared housing. Social & Cultural Geography. 2020;21(1):105-13.
19.       Stone W, Rowley S, Parkinson S, James A, Spinney A. The housing aspirations of Australians across the life-course: Closing the housing aspirations gap (AHURI Final Report No. 337): Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited; 2020.
20.       Artle R, Varaiya P. Life cycle consumption and homeownership. Journal of Economic Theory. 1978;18(1):38-58.
21.       Courant P. Racial prejudice in a search model of the urban housing market. Journal of Urban Economics. 1978;5:329-45.
22.       Li MM. A logit model of homeownership. Econometrica. 1977;45(5):1081-97.
23.       Mayo SK. Theory and estimation in the economics of housing demand. Journal of Urban Economics. 1981;10(1):95-116.
24.       Segal D. The economics of neighborhood: Academic Press; 1979.
25.       Tiebout CM. A pure theory of local expenditures. Journal of Political Economy. 1956;64(5):416-24.
26.       Elder HW, Zumpano LV. Tenure choice, housing demand and residential location. Journal of Real Estate Research. 1991;6(3):341-56.
27.       Gillingham R, Hagemann R. Cross-sectional estimation of a simultaneous model of tenure choice and housing services demand. Journal of Urban Economics. 1983;14:16-39.
28.       King MA. An econometric model of tenure choice and demand for housing as a joint decision. Journal of Public Economics. 1980;14(2):137-59.
29.       Lee L-F, Trost RP. Estimation of some limited dependent variable models with application to housing demand. Journal of Econometrics. 1978;8:357-82.
30.       Rosen HS. Housing decisions and the U.S. income tax: An econometric analysis. Journal of Public Economics. 1979;11(1):1-23.
31.       Heckman JJ, Polachek S. Empirical evidence on the functional form of the earnings-schooling relationship. Journal of the American Statistical Association. 1974;69(346):350-4.
32.       Polinsky AM. The demand for housing: A study in specification and grouping. Econometrica. 1977;45(2):447-61.
33.       McFadden D. Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behavior. In: Zarembka P, editor. Frontiers in econometrics: Academic Press; 1974. p. 105-42.
34.       McFadden D. Modeling the choice of residential location. In: Karlqvist A, Lundqvist L, Snickars F, Weibull JW, editors. Spatial interaction theory and residential location: North-Holland; 1978. p. 75-96.
35.       Pollakowski HO. Urban housing markets and residential location: Lexington Books; 1982.
36.       Boehm TP. A hierarchical model of housing choice. Urban Studies. 1982;19(1):17-31.
37.       Borsch-Supan A, Pitkin J. On discrete choice models of housing demand. Journal of Urban Economics. 1988;24(2):153-72.
38.       Tu Y, Goldfinch J. A two-stage housing choice forecasting model. Urban Studies. 1996;33(3):517-37.
39.       Han X. Housing demand in Shanghai: A discrete choice approach. China Economic Review. 2010;21(3):355-76.
40.       Bhat CR. A comprehensive dwelling unit choice model accommodating psychological constructs within a search strategy for consideration set formation. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological. 2015;79:161-88.
41.       Zolfaghari A, Sivakumar A, Polak JW. Choice set pruning in residential location choice modelling: A comparison of sampling and choice set generation approaches in Greater London. Transport Planning and Technology. 2012;35(1):87-106.
42.       Andrew M, Meen G. Population structure and location choice: A study of London and South East England. Papers in Regional Science. 2006;85(3):401-19.
43.       Eliasson J. The influence of accessibility on residential location: Theory and estimation of an integrated land use-transportation model. In: de Palma T, Lindsey R, Quinet E, Vickerman R, editors. A handbook of transport economics: Edward Elgar; 2010. p. 235-54.
44.       Guevara CA, Ben-Akiva ME. Sampling of alternatives in multivariate extreme value (MEV) models. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological. 2013;48:31-52.
45.       Habib MA, Miller EJ. Reference-dependent residential location choice model within a relocation context. Transportation Research Record. 2009;2133(1):92-9.
46.       Lee BHY, Waddell P. Residential mobility and location choice: A nested logit model with sampling of alternatives. Transportation. 2010;37:587-601.
47.       Pinjari AR, Pendyala RM, Bhat CR, Waddell PA. Modeling the choice continuum: An integrated model of residential location, auto ownership, bicycle ownership, and commute tour mode choice decisions. Transportation. 2011;38:933-58.
48.       Vandeviver C, Van Daele S, Vander Beken T. What makes long crime trips worth undertaking? Balancing costs and benefits in burglars’ journey to crime. British Journal of Criminology. 2015;55(2):399-420.
49.       Guglielminetti E, Loberto M, Zevi G, Zizza R. How work from home changes housing demand: Evidence from online search. AEA Papers and Proceedings. 2023;113:609-13.
50.       Robbennolt D, Haddad AJ, Mondal A, Bhat CR. Housing choice in an evolving remote work landscape. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice. 2024;190:104285.
51.       Lancaster KJ. A new approach to consumer theory. Journal of Political Economy. 1966;74(2):132-57.
52.       Rosen S. Hedonic prices and implicit markets: Product differentiation in pure competition. Journal of Political Economy. 1974;82(1):34-55.
53.       Tiwari P. Housing demand in Tokyo. International Real Estate Review. 2000;3(1):65-92.
54.       Keskin B. Hedonic analysis of price in the Istanbul housing market. International Journal of Strategic Property Management. 2008;12(2):125-38.
55.       Henderson JV, Ioannides YM. A model of housing tenure choice. The American Economic Review. 1983;73(1):98-113.
56.       Morais MP, Cruz BO. Housing demand and tenure choice in Brazilian urban areas (Discussion Paper No. 226): Institute for Applied Economic Research; 2017.
57.       Blackley DM, Follain JR. Inflation, tax advantages to homeownership and the locational choices of households. Regional Science and Urban Economics. 1983;13(4):505-16.
58.       Linneman P, Wachter S. The impacts of borrowing constraints on homeownership. AREUEA Journal. 1989;17(4):389-402.
59.       Deaton A. Understanding consumption: Oxford University Press; 1992.
60.       Neri M, Carvalho A, Nascimento M. Ciclo de vida e motivações financeiras (Ensaios Econômicos EPGE No. 393): Fundação Getulio Vargas; 2000.
61.       Friedman M. A theory of the consumption function: Princeton University Press; 1957.
62.       Daniere A. Determinants of tenure choice in the third world: An empirical study of Cairo and Manila. Journal of Housing Economics. 1992;2(2):159-84.
63.       Koizumi N, McCann P. Living on a plot of land as a tenure choice: The case of Panama. Journal of Housing Economics. 2006;15(4):349-71.
64.       Caliskan B, Özkan Yazar HA, Keskin A. Understanding sociodemographic characteristics shaping the choice of large homes: Lessons from Turkish metropolises. International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis. 2024.
65.       Malpezzi S. A simple error correction model of house prices. Journal of Housing Economics. 1999;8(1):27-62.
66.       Baum S, Wulff M. Housing aspirations of Australian households (AHURI Final Report No. 30): Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited; 2003.
Volume 3, Issue 4 - Serial Number 9
Autumn 2027
Pages 637-674

  • Receive Date 24 April 2026
  • Revise Date 28 June 2026
  • Accept Date 23 August 2026
  • Publish Date 01 January 2027